💼📈 Higher Position vs Higher Salary: Which One Is Better for Your Career?

on

 📌 The Common Dilemma: Title or Take-Home Pay?



You’ve just received a job offer — or maybe you're up for a promotion.

One option gives you a bigger title like Senior Executive or Manager but not much increase in salary.

Another offers a significantly higher salary, but your title and scope remain the same.

So… what should you prioritise?

Let’s break down the pros, cons, and strategic questions to ask yourself.

🏆 Option 1: Higher Position, Lower Salary

✅ Pros:

  1. Career Branding & Future Leverage
    A higher title looks impressive on LinkedIn or a resume, opening doors for future roles with better pay and authority.

  2. Access to Leadership Circles
    You may gain access to higher-level discussions, planning meetings, and visibility with senior management.

  3. Faster Career Progression
    Promotions often follow promotions. A title upgrade can fast-track you into the next level of leadership roles.

  4. More Influence & Decision-Making Power
    You’ll likely have more say in decisions, projects, and team directions — great for building influence and confidence.

  5. Build Soft Skills That Are Hard to Teach
    Strategic thinking, stakeholder management, conflict resolution — these are developed in higher roles, not junior positions.

❌ Cons:

  • You may feel underpaid for the workload

  • Without salary to match, you risk burnout or resentment

  • If the company doesn’t promote based on performance, you might get stuck in a high-responsibility, low-reward trap

  • Perception may matter more than actual value (title inflation without substance)

💰 Option 2: Higher Salary, Lower Position

✅ Pros:

  1. Stronger Financial Base
    Useful for paying off student loans, supporting family, investing, or saving for big life goals.

  2. Freedom to Explore or Upskill
    Higher pay gives you more freedom to pursue online courses, side hustles, or passion projects after work.

  3. Less Pressure, More Focus
    Sometimes, staying in an individual contributor role with less political stress can give you mental peace.

  4. Greater Control Over Work-Life Balance
    With fewer responsibilities tied to “management,” you may have more personal time and boundaries.

  5. You Can Still Negotiate Perks
    Even without a title change, you can negotiate for perks like remote work, extra leave, or bonuses.

❌ Cons:

  • May affect how others perceive your seniority

  • You could become pigeonholed as someone who delivers, but not someone who leads

  • In some industries, career growth is linked to title more than pay

  • Potential for stagnation if you’re not careful with long-term planning

🤔 What About Having Both?

Sometimes, you can negotiate both a better title and salary — but if you can’t, consider:

  • Taking the title, then proving your value to negotiate a raise in 6–12 months

  • Taking the salary, but requesting a title change review after probation

  • Taking a mix: slightly higher salary + slightly improved title + benefits

🎯 Smart employees don’t just accept — they plan, propose, and pivot.

🧭 Key Questions to Ask Yourself Before Deciding:

  1. What’s My Priority Right Now?

    • Financial stability? → Salary

    • Career growth/brand building? → Position

  2. Is This Role Building My Transferable Skills?

    • Strategy, leadership, and decision-making matter long-term

    • So do technical mastery and execution

  3. Can I See Myself in This Role for the Next 1–2 Years?

    • If not, which role makes it easier to pivot?

  4. How Does This Impact My Resume & Recruiter Appeal?

    • Titles often help recruiters understand your trajectory

    • Salary alone is invisible unless it’s matched with a strong track record

  5. What Are My Long-Term Goals — and Does This Get Me Closer?

    • C-suite? Entrepreneurship? Remote lifestyle? Financial independence?

📝 Real-Life Scenarios

📍 A new grad chooses a "Junior Analyst" job with RM5,000 salary over "Project Executive" at RM3,500. Why?
– They want cash now + time to learn, and the Analyst title fits future fintech roles.

📍 An experienced executive picks "Assistant Manager" title at a growing startup over a higher-paying but lateral role at a corporate.
– They aim to build leadership exposure and jump to "Manager" or "Head" within a year.

🎯 Conclusion: Your Career Is a Marathon, Not a Sprint

“Sometimes, a strong title is a ticket to higher income later.
Sometimes, good pay today gives you the freedom to build what matters.”

There’s no one-size-fits-all. The best choice is:
✔️ aligned with your goals
✔️ reflective of your stage of life
✔️ preparing you for what comes next

Choose wisely — and always track your progress so you can re-evaluate every 6–12 months.

Comments

Post a Comment